Welcome to the second installment of Keys to the Library (first here). Today we’ll be covering the weirdos of Stone Age anthropology. Like elsewhere on the fringes, some have proved to be ahead of the science, ahead of the times. Some find themselves behind it—outdated. Others are so detached they are neither ahead nor behind, but a secret third thing.
A reminder before we begin: Keys to the Library is a new series for paid subscribers. All other essays remain free to all. If you’d like to help Neanderthal Paganism grow into books, translations, and other projects, consider becoming a member of the coveted Keys club and grow your library in all things mythology, weird psychology, prehistory, and Neanderthal lore.
A Short Screed
For what they are, Neanderthals aren’t treated nearly as esoterically as they should be.
Empiricists treat them sterilely, as they should. The measured contributions of science are the wind under the wings of anthropology.
But the Stone Age is far too ancient a subject for certainty from either camp. The name itself limits one’s potential conceptions of what the world and its people were like half a million years ago. Did stone dominate the lives of our ancestors, or does it merely dominate what remains of them?
In the nineteenth century, when the inquiry into human origins began, Europe was hot to trot, traversing the globe and the mind with equal voracity—industrializing, exploring, inventing. The deep past became another realm to conquer, and a trendy one at that.
But just like the subjects of imperialism, ancient man was interpreted through a warped lens—looked down upon from the start, and portrayed in a way that affirmed the ego of the interpreting civilization.
For all our advancements since Neanderthals were first discovered in 1856, we really haven’t shaken that first impression. We’re repeatedly told the paradigm has flipped—that Neanderthals “aren’t what we thought.” But even this supposedly revolutionary reassessment leaves little room for the anthropological imagination. Neanderthals can now stand upright, feel empathy, and make jewelry. I’m sure they’d be flattered to know we think so highly of them.
Approaching the subject from the assumption that modern man, with his rapidly rising and falling civilizations, can learn from his ancient ancestors, that his spiritual foundations, the customs and myths whose origins vanish in prehistory, may lie in that ill-defined “Stone Age,” is humbling, but not unfounded or radical.
The difference is that our field of inquiry expands beyond archaeology into dreams and psychology, traditions and folktales. Things often relegated to the periphery of respectable scientific inquiry. Esoterica.
Stan Gooch
“Whereas modern man builds cities of stone, Neanderthal was content to build cities of dreams.”

The Dream Culture of the Neanderthals (1979; retitled 2006): Originally Guardians of the Ancient Wisdom. Emphasizes Neanderthal religion and its supposed survival through lunar symbolism, magic, mythology, and esoteric traditions.

The Neanderthal Legacy (2008): His late-career synthesis, concentrating on inherited psychology, brain structure, genetic hybridization, and the persistence of Neanderthal characteristics in modern humanity.

Cities of Dreams (1989; revised 1995): Probably the most expansive treatment of Neanderthal civilization, its imagined social and spiritual world, and the supposed consequences of its encounter with modern humans.
Perhaps the most well-known outsider in Neanderthal studies is Stan Gooch (1932-2010), who started out as an accomplished psychologist before fleeing the academic establishment under the impression that his discipline, like many others, had fallen under a spell of self-assuredness in the mid-twentieth century.
“A leading and respected psychologist…confided in me that in her view in only a few years’ time we would know everything there was to know about human psychology and human society. This comment, which left me completely stunned for several days, was among the reasons why I felt I had to leave the psychological establishment.
It was, however, by no means the first such comment I had heard, either before or since, not just from psychologists, but from leading biologists, anthropologists, doctors, historians – the pillars of the academic establishment – the view that, really, we were well on the way to knowing everything about mankind. In all fields relating to human evolution, to the human psyche, it was pretty much a question only of tying up the loose ends.”
It was made apparent to Gooch that the humility required for honest inquiry was conspicuously absent from the academic establishment, whose confidence in its conclusions seemed to leave increasingly little room for dissent.
Gooch’s breakaway would culminate firstly in the 1972 publication of Total Man, and Personality and Evolution: The Biology of the Divided Self a year later. These early works were well received, with Publisher’s Weekly even drawing a comparison between Gooch and Carl Jung. He seemed to be on his way to becoming part of the influential counterculture that emerged during that era.
His subsequent foray into The Neanderthal Question, the 1977 follow-up to his two books from earlier in the decade, would decidedly diminish his potential for worldly acclaim in his lifetime. Apparently, the consciousness of 1977 was not prepared for an in-depth investigation into the cultural legacy of Neanderthals. However, for Gooch, taking a path that he would later admit led him toward alienation as a researcher and financial woes was worth remaining true to his interests.
The recurring assertion in Gooch’s work is that hybridization between Neanderthals and Sapiens (that he refers to as Cro-Magnon) created our current “divided self.” Neanderthal culture is the basis of all things chthonic and creative, while Cro-Magnons represent a dominant, solar, hunting culture that ultimately supplanted it. When the two species met, they merged genetically but clashed culturally, initiating a legacy of conflict that continues to manifest today in everything from one’s tendency to choose a certain career to having more conservative or liberal opinions. Gooch therefore implies direct inheritance from Neanderthals who were thought of as having gone extinct without a trace 40,000 years ago. His books are chock-full of observations of human behavior and how it fits into his overarching theory about the ancient hybridization that caused modern man’s dual nature.
For example, it was Gooch’s belief that the cerebellum, conventionally associated with motor coordination, was also the seat of dreams, intuition, and unconscious mental activity. He associated this deeper realm of consciousness with our Neanderthal inheritance, contrasting it with the rational, cerebral faculties he attributed to Cro-Magnon.
It was from the Neanderthal culture of the mind, Gooch argues, that we’ve inherited our ideas about reincarnation and otherworldly realms. Our distance from these ideas, a result of the Cro-Magnon cultural and genetic dominance, is the reason why we tend to misinterpret or lack a full understanding of things like mythology, pre-Christian traditions, and the symbolism found in ancient cultures and Paleolithic caves. Similarly, the reason why the intuitive, cerebral realm, whether it be the veneration of wisdom and intuition, or poetry and the arts, is separated in our minds from the realm of reason, science, and criticism, is due to this ancient struggle between Neanderthals and Cro-Magnons.
“I am not arguing at all for any kind of full-scale ‘golden age’ from which we have since fallen away. But I do believe, it is clear, that Neanderthal man had, from certain points of view, an advanced culture, one far more advanced than he is currently given credit for. Although his central frame of reference was religion, and though his terminology was that of symbolism, I think he nevertheless did have a fair grasp of many hard biological and psychological facts, and to some extent the facts of geology and physics.”
In 2010, the year of Gooch’s death, perhaps the most significant breakthrough in Neanderthal studies since their initial discovery occurred. Data published by an international research team led by Richard Green, working with Svante Pääbo, demonstrated that modern humans carry genetic material inherited from Neanderthals. Whatever one makes of Gooch’s more extravagant theories, the premise of Neanderthal interbreeding, once enough to invite skepticism, could no longer be dismissed.
One might not subscribe to every aspect of his ideas, but it remains that Gooch pursued deep underlying questions about human origins, evaluating the Neanderthal legacy long before their intelligence and cultural sophistication received the widespread recognition they enjoy today.


